I often wonder how things would be if the leaders of society were elected via a tournament

Creamer

Well-known member
Messages
806
#1
a video game tournament or an MMA style match, or even that Japanese go game.

what we have now is a popularity contest for the rich kids.
 

Admin

Administrator
Moderator
Messages
3,677
#2
It would likely work better than democracy assuming the same level of compliance with how it's supposed to work (government officials not cheating, people having faith in the system, etc) since the selection criteria would likely be better than random selection and it would reduce the number of people involved in the highest levels of governance.

But it would also not be ideal since being good at go may not translate into actually doing a good job governing a country and more importantly many people suited for governing would not be good enough to win a go tournament or at least not have time for that. It would favor people who put all their effort into winning at the game rather than actually being good when it comes to actual governance.

One option is to invent a new board-game when it's time to evaluate each new official. Even here however people could get an advantage by having played similar games in the past.
 
Top