About "kämpfer" and "kashimashi girl meets girl"

[Admin]

Anime like "kämpfer" and "kashimashi girl meets girl" (forced MtF) presents a very appealing idealized version if what it means to be female.

If you look at their societies they are essentially ideal, not too high-tech, people having fun actually meeting each other doing cool things. In reality a lot if females are unhappy chasing instagram validation and we all have to deal with crime, corruption and government dysfunction.

Interestingly in kämpfer they do not really try to make their society seem super-great, for example the school is exploiting the main character (who turned female), in addition the main character has engage in some grand nonsensical struggle (white, blue, red kämpfers). It's also unrealistic in the sense that all females are obsessed with her and wants to have sex with her when in reality most females prefer men to have sex with.

The society in kashimashi girl meets girl is a lot more idealized. A better example of a medium-tech utopia we see in some japanese anime.

 

[Admin]

Lack of adult responsibilities
With these idealized animes the main-characters do not have to worry about their economy. Instead the main-characters are in school where they can meet a lot of people and then have fun outside school.

In reality however for society to function a lot of people do need to work. Some people will of course live on welfare but that is only possible thanks to other people working and paying taxes. The issue with living on welfare as a male is that then you will not earn much money and you will have a hard time attracting a female partner, your social life will probably not be too great (if you have a social life at all).

I think part of the appeal with universities (and why they remain very popular) is that people think it will allow them to have a great social life (especially if you live where you study). The issue is that the social life you are experiencing in school is not actually genuine, it's kinda forced and will typically not last once you stop going to that school/university.

 

[Admin]

Can you get something like that as a trans female today?
In some bigger cities you might be able to get some great things as a transbian (trans female attracted to females) since then there will be a big pool of transbian there and you can join/form some transbian community. The biggest issue is that the smaller the city the less chance you will have of finding a transbian community to join, you might find yourself socially isolated due to not fitting in with the trans community where you live.

If you just date other trans females you will probably not reproduce, this does mean less responsibility but it's not really a great thing. It may at first seem like not having to take responsibility for raising children is a plus but in reality it just makes your life kinda pointless. I do recommend that you try to have biological children even if you pursue medical transition.

 

[Admin]

One nice thing about Kämpfer is his/her ability to switch back and forth between the sexes (at first he/she cannot control it), this is a nice break from the reality we face where gender transition is difficult and to a large extent irreversible (crossdressing is an option but it's very much not the same).

 

[Admin]

Kishimashi girl meets girl is a masterpiece
One of the best aspect of the anime is the personality of the main character. The show does a very good job in making you like him/her and it's nice to follow her growth.

Far too many shows have a male main character is creepy incel but in this show the main character never make a big deal about things like nudity itself, instead the focus of the show is the social interactions. The nudity of the show is very limited and used for immersion rather than trying to provide the viewers with sexual excitement.

The show also does a good job illustrating how changing your sex can come with some challanges, her closest friend had a hard time accepting her change to a female.

Watching the show you to get the impression that the main character do like being female even though he/she never consented to changing his/her sex. The main character seem to care more about other people around her than her body, this is the opposite of how a lot of people are today where they are obsessed with how they look and spend a lot of money on makeup, surgeries, etc.

 

[Admin]

Most male to trans incels will still not pass and lead relatively difficult lives even when they transisition though, so presenting it as an ideal solution to inceldom is a bit fraudulent.

Who is presenting it as some ideal solution to inceldom?

You are correct that very often passing is difficult to impossible so it will not be the same as being a cis female. The issue with early transition however is that for young people it will be a lot harder to predict who is going to end up as incel, maybe someone who struggle with dating at 17 will do just fine at 20. You might be able to escape inceldom just by becoming financially successful.

Current medical transition options are still rather limited, no successful womb transplant has been done yet.

Transitioning will also bring you gender issues specific to the sex you are transitioning to in addition to potential social issues from being trans.

I think most serious societal issues apply both to males and females.

 

[dsar9012]

Who is presenting it as some ideal solution to inceldom?

You are correct that very often passing is difficult to impossible so it will not be the same as being a cis female. The issue with early transition however is that for young people it will be a lot harder to predict who is going to end up as incel, maybe someone who struggle with dating at 17 will do just fine at 20.

Yeah, I agree with that, so why do you encourage trannymaxing? Or is it that somebody else on this site?

 

[dsar9012]

I don't like tranny culture at all, mainly due to the liberalism. But it's your life. I believe trannycels are pretty cowardly but I can't blame them. I believe this is a female supremacist society. Their lives will still be a lot easier after they transition. I was reading some conservative site today even though I hate Republicucks, but trannies got some Chad actor fired because he said that a male looking tranny was a dude. Twitter leftists and trannies got him fired. It wasn't a passing tranny at all keep in mind. Trannies have vastly more privilege in liberal society than white male incels, they even have more privilege than white male Chads, even if the Chad has a better life of fucking hot women etc. If a social battle was between some Chad and an ugly incel that became a tranny, society would favor the tranny. So I understand why incels who have failed at life would become trannies. BUT I see it as being cowards, because incels should come together to challenge female supremacy. That won't happen though.

 

[Admin]

Yeah, I agree with that, so why do you encourage trannymaxing? Or is it that somebody else on this site?

For some people transitioning still improves their life but it's of course not (and probably never will be) an effective solution to the incel problem.